The folks at Touchstone Magazine (Wilfred McClay, Russell Moore, S. M. Hutchens, D. G. Hart, and David Mills) respond in a critical symposium to "A Call to an Ancient Evangelical Future," which was published in Christianity Today and convened by Robert Webber and Philip Kenyon, with theological editors Hans Boersma, Howard Snyder, Kevin J. Vanhoozer, and D. H. Williams.